EXTREME Overclocking - Power Supply Testing Methodology Article - Page: 5
Home | Reviews | Forums | Downloads | $ EXTREME Deals $ | RealTime Pricing | Free Magazines | Gear | Wiki | Folding Stats Newsletter | Contact Us

Power Supply Testing Methodology
at EXTREME Overclocking

Date Published: June 2, 2005
Page Last Updated: February 20, 2006
Author: Jason Rabel

 

Compiled Test Results - Loading:

Loads are reported at 4 different levels (Low, Typical, Heavy, and Max), the numbers will vary slightly between power supplies because voltage levels have a direct effect on current going though the resistors. Ambient temperature (outside the case) would vary between 23.8-26.7°C (75-80°F), which was somewhat proportional to the load level being tested, however the main concern was keeping the internal temp below 50°C. All PC power supplies are "switching power supplies", so please keep in mind that voltage levels will always vary between PCs because loads are always different (and quite dynamic).

  • Things to consider:
    1. Voltage Regulation (% above/below nominal)
    2. Efficiency (particularly under a "typical" & "heavy" loads)
    3. Safety (Does it shutdown under unsafe conditions?)
    4. Maximum Real Power Output (does it meet rated output?)
    • Two potential reason a power supply did not meet its rated maximum power output:
      1. Voltage exceeded maximum tolerances (as specified on previous page)
      2. PSU shutdown (overheat or overload condition)

Note: Maximum tested load (red background) may not always be the maximum PSU output rating (mentioned as reason #4 above). We try to get as close as possible to the maximum rated output, but the design of the load testing device only works in incremental numbers.

Akasa PaxPower 460W - AK-P460FG
3.3V 5V 12V1 12V2 5Vsb -12V DC Load AC Input Effic PF Case
Volts Amps Volts Amps Volts Amps Volts Amps Volts Volts Watts Watts % - °C
3.42 3.36 5.20 1.06 12.06 3.11 12.07 3.06 5.05 11.60 96.3 134 71.9 .98 33.5
3.39 6.41 5.19 6.21 12.06 6.15 12.05 8.96 5.05 11.94 241.0 310 77.8 .99 35.6
3.39 14.51 5.17 10.58 12.05 12.10 12.05 11.77 5.06 12.21 396.5 520 76.3 .99 38.5
3.39 14.37 5.15 14.95 12.06 14.96 12.06 14.46 5.06 12.42 485.5 662 73.3 .99 47.5
Note: 5Vsb & -12V rails have fixed resistors at approximately .5A & .2A respectively.

  Load PF 3.3V 5V 12V1 12V2 Effic Case
Akasa
PowerPlus
Rated: 650W
PFC: Active
ATX: 2.01
EPS: 2.11		 102W .98 3.34
(2%)		 5.15
(3%)		 12.19
(2%)		 12.18
(2%)		 73.9% 23.1°C
257W .99 3.31
(1%)		 5.09
(2%)		 12.18
(2%)		 12.14
(2%)		 83.1% 31.3°C
423W .99 3.24
(-1%)		 5.03
(1%)		 12.15
(2%)		 12.13
(2%)		 82.1% 42.2°C
635W .99 3.20
(-3%)		 4.90
(-2%)		 12.19
(2%)		 12.17
(2%)		 78.8% 49.9°C

Comments:

 Even with the load tester maxed out, the PSU still ran strong. Voltages typically within 2% tolerance, adjustable pots can allow for exact precision if desired. Good efficiency, >80% under typical loads.
 
Antec
SP-500
Rated: 500W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.0		 96W .58 3.31
(1%)		 5.07
(2%)		 12.16
(2%)		 12.14
(2%)		 79% 26.7°C
242W .60 3.27
(-1%)		 5.03
(1%)		 12.08
(1%)		 12.00
(0%)		 82% 38.6°C
397W .62 3.21
(-3%)		 4.97
(-1%)		 11.95
(-1%)		 11.91
(-1%)		 78% 51.0°C
514W .64 3.21
(-3%)		 4.86
(-3%)		 11.97
(-1%)		 11.92
(-1%)		 75% 55.6°C

Comments:

 12V rails loaded to ~18A each (max we can test), stayed within 1% tolerance. Good voltage regulation overall, 3.3V dipped a little under very heavy loads.
 
Antec
TP-II 480 Blue
Rated: 480W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.01		 92W .57 3.36
(2%)		 5.12
(3%)		 12.08
(1%)		 12.07
(1%)		 73% 32.2°C
240W .59 3.33
(1%)		 5.08
(2%)		 12.04
(1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 80% 37.1°C
403W .61 3.27
(-1%)		 5.04
(1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 11.92
(-1%)		 79% 43.3°C
498W .61 3.27
(-1%)		 5.03
(1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 11.90
(-1%)		 77% 46.1°C

Comments:

 Awesome voltage regulation, generally 1%! Properly shutdown from over-current and over-temp conditions. Tested to ~530W peak.
 
Cooler Master
RS-550-ACLY
Rated: 550W
PFC: Active
ATX: 2.01		 96W .97 3.34
(2%)		 5.10
(2%)		 12.11
(1%)		 12.10
(1%)		 82% 30.7°C
240W .99 3.29
(1%)		 5.02
(1%)		 12.04
(1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 83% 34.5°C
397W .99 3.20
(-3%)		 4.93
(-2%)		 11.91
(-1%)		 11.88
(-1%)		 80% 40.4°C
461W .99 3.21
(-3%)		 4.96
(-1%)		 11.80
(-2%)		 11.76
(-2%)		 79% 42.2°C

Comments:

 Specs showed derating 85% of full loading operation at 40°C. Good tolerances and efficiency levels. Peak output ~650W under more nominal temperatures.
 

Enermax Liberty 620W - ELT620AWT
3.3V 5V 12V1 12V2 5Vsb -12V DC Load AC Input Effic PF Case
Volts Amps Volts Amps Volts Amps Volts Amps Volts Volts Watts Watts % - °C
3.36 3.37 5.21 1.06 12.20 3.15 12.20 3.08 5.18 12.02 97.9 121 80.9 .98 32.3
3.40 6.53 5.21 6.25 12.20 6.25 12.19 6.22 5.17 12.05 245.4 290 84.6 .99 34.3
3.42 14.68 5.22 10.67 12.21 12.25 12.21 11.88 5.16 12.05 405.5 486 83.4 .99 41.7
3.47 21.63 5.19 26.71 12.32 18.07 12.32 17.42 5.14 12.07 655.9 833 78.7 .99 47.4
Note: 5Vsb & -12V rails have fixed resistors at approximately .5A & .2A respectively.

Enermax
EG475P-VE
Rated: 470W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.0		 98W .59 3.35
(2%)		 5.20
(4%)		 12.18
(2%)		 12.17
(2%)		 82% 29.2°C
242W .61 3.30
(0%)		 5.14
(3%)		 12.09
(1%)		 11.97
(-1%)		 85% 37.4°C
397W .63 3.21
(-3%)		 5.07
(2%)		 11.94
(-1%)		 11.85
(-2%)		 82% 43.7°C
463W .62 3.20
(-3%)		 5.08
(2%)		 11.84
(-2%)		 11.72
(-3%)		 81% 47.3°C

Comments:

 Held up exceptionally well under various load conditions. Capable of 480-500W continuous output with heavy 12V usage under average ambient temps.
 
HEC
ACE Power
Rated: 480W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.01		 97W .59 3.38
(3%)		 5.17
(4%)		 12.07
(1%)		 12.04
(1%)		 78% 29.6°C
242W .61 3.34
(2%)		 5.10
(2%)		 12.08
(1%)		 11.97
(-1%)		 80% 36.7°C
407W .63 3.27
(-1%)		 5.02
(1%)		 12.06
(1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 78% 46.7°C
470W .63 3.25
(-2%)		 5.03
(1%)		 11.99
(-1%)		 11.88
(-1%)		 76% 51°C

Comments:

 12V Rails loaded each to ~17.5A, voltages still stayed within 2% of tolerance. Dual 80mm fans were very quiet, even under heavy load. Good voltage regulation.
 
Hiper
Type-R 580W
Rated: 580W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.2		 100W .60 3.39
(3%)		 5.22
(5%)		 12.28
(3%)		 12.23
(2%)		 77.4% 21.2°C
247W .61 3.35
(2%)		 5.12
(3%)		 12.20
(2%)		 12.06
(1%)		 80.9% 31.2°C
408W .61 3.25
(-2%)		 5.08
(2%)		 12.09
(1%)		 11.95
(-1%)		 78.1% 38.3°C
562W .60 3.20
(-3%)		 4.97
(-1%)		 11.98
(-1%)		 11.87
(-1%)		 74.8% 42.2°C

Comments:

 Good Efficiency, ~78-80% under typical loads. All voltages stayed within acceptable tolerances. Very quiet fans.
 
Hiper
Type-R 480W
Rated: 480W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.2		 99W .62 3.38
(3%)		 5.11
(3%)		 11.97
(-1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 79.9% 21.6°C
247W .60 3.32
(1%)		 5.03
(1%)		 11.88
(-1%)		 11.83
(-2%)		 84.2% 32.3°C
400W .58 3.23
(-2%)		 4.94
(-2%)		 11.73
(-3%)		 11.74
(-3%)		 79.9% 40.1°C
482W .58 3.17
(-4%)		 4.81
(-4%)		 11.68
(-3%)		 11.74
(-3%)		 76.3% 44.3°C

Comments:

 PSU would NOT shutdown from an over-current situation and resulted in damage. 12V rails loaded each to ~18A, voltages were within 4% of tolerance. Verified peak load rating of 530W.
 
Meridian
XClio-450BL
Rated: 450W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.0		 95W .59 3.28
(-1%)		 5.09
(2%)		 12.16
(2%)		 12.15
(2%)		 77% 31.9°C
238W .60 3.26
(-2%)		 5.05
(1%)		 12.09
(1%)		 12.00
(0%)		 81% 37.3°C
398W .61 3.20
(-3%)		 4.99
(-1%)		 12.01
(1%)		 11.96
(-1%)		 77% 41.7°C
460W .61 3.20
(-3%)		 5.02
(1%)		 11.86
(-2%)		 11.80
(-2%)		 76% 44.8°C

Comments:

 Good Efficiency and regulation. Shut down properly from over-temp & over-current conditions. Tested to ~550W peak. Includes fan adapter (SCFT) for cooling after shutdown.
 
Meridian
XCLIO-550BL
Rated: 550W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.01		 98W .58 3.34
(2%)		 5.09
(2%)		 12.15
(2%)		 12.13
(2%)		 76% 32.3°C
241W .59 3.28
(-1%)		 5.02
(1%)		 12.08
(1%)		 11.98
(-1%)		 80% 37.2°C
396W .62 3.17
(-4%)		 4.94
(-2%)		 11.97
(-1%)		 11.90
(-1%)		 77% 41.8°C
528W .63 3.20
(-3%)		 4.85
(-3%)		 11.92
(-1%)		 11.83
(-2%)		 75% 45.8°C

Comments:

 Rubberized coating. Made by Channel Well Technologies, same design as Antec True Power 2.0. Loaded both 12V rails to 18A each, stayed 1% tolerance.
 
OCZ
ModStream
52012U
Rated: 520W
PFC: None
ATX: 1.3		 93W .59 3.37
(2%)		 5.15
(3%)		 11.93
(-1%)		 79% 30.6°C
239W .61 3.32
(1%)		 5.11
(3%)		 11.77
(-2%)		 82% 37.0°C
389W .64 3.23
(-2%)		 5.04
(1%)		 11.67
(-3%)		 75% 43.9°C
502W .64 3.20
(-3%)		 4.95
(-1%)		 11.64
(-3%)		 71% 45.6°C

Comments:

 Shut down properly from over-temp & over-current conditions. Tested +12V up to 35A peak load (max test rig can do).
 
Seasonic
S12-500W
Rated: 500W
PFC: Active
ATX: 2.0		 95W .96 3.31
(1%)		 4.98
(-1%)		 12.04
(1%)		 12.03
(1%)		 80% 28.0°C
239W .99 3.28
(-1%)		 4.95
(-1%)		 12.01
(1%)		 11.94
(-1%)		 85% 37.7°C
393W .99 3.20
(-3%)		 4.90
(-2%)		 11.93
(-1%)		 11.88
(-1%)		 83% 44.8°C
507W .99 3.18
(-4%)		 4.84
(-4%)		 11.89
(-1%)		 11.83
(-2%)		 82% 49.6°C

Comments:

 Excellent efficiency, 85% under typical load! Also has active PFC! ould not get PSU to shutdown from current or temp overload. Voltage levels would just continue to drop and current would never go higher than about 720W (AC, so figure about 560W DC).
 
Sunbeamtech
NUUO-550W
Rated: 550W
PFC: None
ATX: 2.0		 97W .57 3.42
(4%)		 5.14
(3%)		 12.06
(1%)		 12.04
(1%)		 75% 25.3°C
247W .59 3.40
(3%)		 5.11
(3%)		 12.00
(0%)		 11.92
(-1%)		 82% 34.3°C
400W .60 3.35
(2%)		 5.06
(2%)		 11.92
(-1%)		 11.85
(-2%)		 78% 39.9°C
532W .61 3.32
(1%)		 4.96
(-2%)		 11.89
(-1%)		 11.81
(-2%)		 77% 43.7°C

Comments:

 NVIDIA SLI Certified. Good voltage regulation. Properly shutdown from overload conditions. Dual fan design reasonably quiet.
 
TTGI
TT-550K14
Rated: 550W
PFC: None
ATX: 1.3		 93W .61 3.43
(4%)		 5.15
(3%)		 11.75
(-3%)		 72% 30.5°C
224W .62 3.38
(3%)		 5.07
(2%)		 11.44
(-5%)		 77% 34.8°C
N/A Voltages exceeded specified tolerances
445W .65 3.22
(-3%)		 4.81
(-4%)		 11.91
(-1%)		 69% 41.1°C

Comments:

 Requires more load than average on 5V & 3.3V to keep voltages balances. Unable to load 12V beyond ~20A without voltage dropping below 5% or overloading PSU (by increasing load on other rails to compensate).
 

I would estimate about a ±2% margin of error for load ratings & efficiency calculations.

If you have any questions / comments / concerns or whatever about the results, please feel free to contact me (link up in the title area).

 

EXTREME Overclocking Newsletter
Thousands of PC enthusiasts are already subscribed to the EXTREME Overclocking Newsletter, have you signed up yet?
Your Email Address:
Sponsored Links
Latest Reviews
Most Downloaded Files
Recently Added Files
CPU-Z 1.455/16/08
Compare Prices On Top Brands!
Search:
For:

Intel Core 2 Processors
 Kentsfield (LGA 775)
QX6850  QX6800  QX6700  Q6700  Q6600
Conroe (LGA 775)
X6800  E6850  E6750  E6700  E6600  E6550  E6420  E6400  E6320  E6300
Allendale (LGA 775)
E4500  E4400  E4300

AMD Athlon 64 Processors
 Brisbane (AM2) X2
5000+  4800+  4400+  4000+  BE-2350  BE-2300
Windsor (Socket F) X2
FX-74  FX-72  FX-70
Windsor (AM2) X2
FX-62  6400+  6000+  5600+  5400+  5200+  4600+  4200+  3800+
Orleans (AM2)
4000+  3800+  3500+  3200+  3000+

AMD Opteron Processors
 Santa Rosa (Socket F)
2224 SE  2222 SE  2220  2218 HE  2216 HE  2214 HE  2212 HE  2210 HE
Santa Ana (AM2)
1222  1220  1218  1216  1214  1212  1210
Santa Ana (AM2)
1216 HE  1214 HE  1212 HE  1210 HE
Denmark (939)
185  180  175  170  165

DDR3 Memory
 PC3-14400  PC3-12800  PC3-11000  PC3-10666  PC3-10600  PC3-8500

DDR2 Memory
 PC2-9600  PC2-8500  PC2-8000  PC2-7200  PC2-6400  PC2-5400  PC2-5300  PC2-4200

DDR Memory
 PC-4200  PC-4000  PC-3500  PC-3500  PC-2700

Motherboards
 ABIT  ASUS  AOpen  Biostar  DFI  Gigabyte  Intel  MSI  Shuttle  Tyan

Video Cards
 ATi  BFG  Leadtek  MSI  nVidia  PowerColor  PNY  Sapphire  Visiontek  XFX

Hard Drives
 Seagate  Maxtor  Samsung  Fujitsu  Western Digital

  Technology Magazines FREE to Qualified Professionals.
eWeek MagazineeWeek is the essential technology information source for builders of e-business. Focuses on e-commerce, communications and Internet-based architecture. Oracle MagazineOracle Magazine contains technology-strategy articles, sample code, tips, Oracle and partner news, how-to articles for developers and DBAs, and more. Dr. Dobb's JournalDr. Dobb's Journal enables programmers to write the most efficient and sophisticated programs and help in daily programming quandaries. InformationWeekInformationWeek is the only newsweekly you'll need to stay on top of the latest developments in information technology.
  Other Popular Titles: PC Magazine, BusinessWeek, Baseline, Business Solutions, Software Magazine, InfoStor, Security Source , TelevisionWeek, more...
  EXTREME Deal Of The Day | More EXTREME Deals
Dell Home - Dell Studio 15 Laptop from Only $949 with the NEW Mini 9 for Only $99 Extra!
We've got some Mini deals for you folks,... they all expire today so if you want it, get it today.

Dell Small Business - Dell Vostro 410 Tower Computer with Core 2 QUAD Q6600 Processor, 1GB of Memory, 128MB ATI Radeon Video and 80GB Hard Drive for Only $499 with FREE Shipping!
If you're looking for a Quad processor desktop computer with which to build from, this is a hot one to start from. At only $499, it comes with a $99 value Windows XP Professional "downgrade" installed along with a a nice 128mb ATI Radeon video. DELL VOSTRO 410 TOWER CORE 2 QUAD Q6600 PROCESSOR DESKTOP COMPUTER DEAL

  • Don't forget to check out Dell's current desktop deals that feature a Vostro 200 with a 19" LCD ofr $474, a Vostro 410 with a 20" LCD for $749 and their business class Optiplex series desktops. DELL DESKTOP DEALS
Copyright © 2000-2008 EXTREME Overclocking. All rights reserved.
Disclaimer of Liability - Privacy Policy