|
CompuNurse Temp Probe
Product: CompuNurse Temperature Probe
Street Price: Around $14 USD
Date Reviewed: August 20, 2001
Reviewed By: Jason
Rabel
What Is It?:
In a nutshell the CompuNurse is a little battery powered
digital temperature probe. The probe itself is very flat and is at the
end of a cord about 3' long. Here is a quick rundown of the
specifications:
-
Range: -40°C to 90°C
-
Resolution: .01°C (max
0.3°C)
-
Accuracy: 1°C
-
Display: Constant readout
-
Sampling: 3 second sampling
cycle
-
Sensor Cord: 800mm cold
resistant PVC cable
-
Battery: G10 (1PC)
The CompuNurse is small enough to fit a couple of them on a
5 1/4" block off plate. Tou can get a general idea of the CompuNurse from the picture below, the digital readout is very easy to
read from various angles, and the temperature probe is long enough to
reach just about any area in a full tower case with enough slack to
route the cord out of the way.

(Click To Enlarge) The CompuNurse only displays in Celsius which
probably isn't a big deal for most of the world, but us people in the US are
used to Fahrenheit and I actually have a little conversion table printout handy so I know
exactly what the temperature is in a format that I'm accustom to. Also, the CompuNurse is battery powered so it is always on. While it doesn't consume that
much power, I think incorporating some sort of switch would of been nice to help
extend battery life. But also being battery powered gives it a lot more
possibilities and portability. What can you do
with it? My intention when I bought the CompuNurse was
to place it on the top of my CPU and monitor to monitor the core's temperature
(and to see how accurate the thermistor on the bottom of the CPU was). However
when I first set the probe on the CPU I noticed that a bit of the heat shrink
tubing was overlapping on ceramic part of the CPU, and it was so thick that a
heat sink wouldn't sit flush. My solution was to take a knife and
shave off the excess heat shrink tubing until it cleared the ceramic edge of the
CPU.

(Click To Enlarge) Yes that knife is a Spyderco, I've had it for
about 5 years and I use it all the time and it is still razor sharp. Anyhow, you
can see from the second picture that I have removed some of the heat shrink
tubing and just exposed more of the flat plastic layer that encases the temp
probe. Next I measured the thickness with my dial caliper to see
if it would clear the CPU core.

(Click To Enlarge)
The thickness is right at .019" which is more than ample room to clear both
Intel & AMD CPU's. Just so you know, an Intel CPU core is about .033" high, and
an AMD CPU core is about .031" high. So next I mounted the temp probe touching a
corner of the CPU core and used a piece of tape to hold it in place. Next I ran
some tests to see how it compared to the thermistor mounted on the motherboard
under the CPU.

(Click To Enlarge)
How Does It Compare?: Here is a
little chart to compare the CompuNurse to the onboard thermistor:
Testing was done using a KT7A-RAID with a 1GHz Athlon (Courtesy
of PCNut) overclocked to
1.13GHz (8.5 x 133), running at 2.05v (for added heat).
| Ambient Temperature: |
| 82.1F +/- .5F |
27.8C +/- .5C |
|
Heat Sink Model |
CPU Idle CompuNurse |
CPU Load
CompuNurse |
CPU Idle Onboard |
CPU Load Onboard |
| Vantec CCK-6035D |
90.9F |
32.7C |
120.4F |
49.1C |
90F |
32.2C |
120.2F |
49C |
| Thermaltake Dragon Orb 3 |
90.9F |
32.7C |
126.5F |
52.5C |
90F |
32.2C |
125.6F |
52C |
| GlobalWin CAK38 |
91.4F |
33.0C |
121.1F |
49.5C |
91F |
32.8C |
120.2F |
49C |
As you can see, the temperatures stayed within 1 degree of each
other. Seeing as how the CompuNurse is rated to 1°C accuracy and it is touching
the CPU core on the top, the MB thermistor touching the bottom of the CPU seems
to be pretty accurate since it is keeping inline with the CompuNurse. Even after
using 3 different heat sinks the numbers stayed pretty consistent.
Conclusions: Since not all
motherboards have the ability to monitor CPU temperature, this is an excellent
and inexpensive alternative. While I probably wouldn't bother keeping this on a
CPU that already has a thermistor touching the bottom (like my board which is
the ABIT KT7-A) since those numbers seem to be fairly accurate, I would use it
on some older motherboards that don't have that luxury of monitoring the CPU
core. I would also consider it a necessity when testing heat sinks to get the
most accurate readout possible. Another use might be to measure the core
temperature on your video card, or air temperature coming off of certain fans,
or even water temperature if your rig is setup like that (take extra caution
though!). The only big gripe I have is that there is no
Fahrenheit readout, would it of really been that difficult & expensive to add a
little switch in the back to go between Fahrenheit & Celsius?
Other than that one little discrepancy, I like the CompuNurse and would
recommend it to any person that is wanting to monitor some temperature in their
system. Pros:
Inexpensive
Accurate
Battery Powered
Long Cord For Probe
Can Fit Under CPU / GPU
Cons:
Readout Only In Celsius
Battery Powered
Rating:
For The Average User: 9 / 10
For The Extreme Overclocker: 9 / 10
Back To The Main Page
|