|
Copper Shims
Company: TweakMonster, OCZ,
CPUFX
Product: TweakMonster Copper Shims
Street Price: Around $10 USD
Date Reviewed: March 13, 2001
Reviewed By: Jason
Rabel
How
Do They Fit?: You can see below, the AMD shim fits
very nicely, and there is plenty of extra space round the L1 bridges where you
pencil in the traces. The P3 shim is on the right, and it is designed for FCPGA
only (like you really need a shim for a Slot-1). This P3 shim is much larger and
nicer than the CPUFX brand, and best of all, it works! You can see that over time
(before I got this shim) my P3 has many chips on the corners, and I was getting a little worried
about it, but now with the TweakMonster shim I'm not worried anymore about
chipping the corners because the shim fits so well. 
How
Do They Compare?: You can find the specifications for the CPU's
in public datasheets available on the Intel & AMD web sites. The
specifications are given in a minimum and maximum tolerance, however looking for
an exact target number I took the average of the two guessing that is the number
that production shoots for. Note that Intel has a narrower tolerance range, half
that of AMD, but the average still comes out within two thousandths of an inch.
| |
Min |
Max |
Var |
Avg |
| Intel |
.031" |
.035" |
.004" |
.033" |
| AMD |
.027" |
.035" |
.008" |
.031" |
So now that we have a baseline to compare against, which we will
say is .033" for Intel and .031" for AMD, we can measure the thickness
of the copper shims to see how they compare. I took many measurements across
the entire area of the shims to check for fluctuations in thickness (which we
don't want).
| |
Min |
Max |
Var |
| TweakMonster AMD |
.027" |
.027" |
.000" |
| TweakMonster Intel |
.027" |
.027" |
.000" |
| OCZ AMD |
.027" |
.027" |
.000" |
| CPUFX AMD |
.027" |
.030" |
.003" |
| CPUFX Intel |
.020" |
.021" |
.001" |
Conclusions: So
how do we interpret these results? First I will tell you that all the shims
except for the CPUFX Intel fit snugly and didn't slide around when used. The
CPUFX Intel shim was so thin that it never made contact with the heatsink and
would slide around freely (very bad). The TweakMonster shims, because they are
CNC machined have a perfect thickness of .027", which is slightly thinner
than our "average" CPU, yet thick enough to protect against chipping.
The shim that came from OCZ which was also a TweakMonster shim was the exact
same thickness too; this demonstrates the high quality that can be achieved with
a CNC machine. The CPUFX AMD shim did vary in thickness up to .030" which
is actually in the "red zone" tolerance wise, if you had an AMD CPU
that was on the lower end of AMD's tolerance, then you could possibly fry your
CPU because the heatsink couldn't make good contact with the core because the
shim is too thick. The CPUFX Intel shim was way too thin to do anything but
cause problems.
Bottom line, if you want something to be precisely cut
then CNC is the way to go. I can say with confidence that the
TweakMonster shims are excellent products and do exactly what they are
supposed to. Beware of the CPUFX shims, you are taking a serious gamble
if you want to try and use one of theirs on your CPU.
OCZ
is one of the many places that resell the TweakMonster shims, you can
check out their website for more info, and also check out TweakMonster
for more info.
Pro's:
CNC Machined For Precise Cutting
Fit Perfect
Good Price
Con's:
None
Back To The Main Page
|
eWeek is the essential technology information source for builders of e-business. Focuses on e-commerce, communications and Internet-based architecture.
Oracle Magazine contains technology-strategy articles, sample code, tips, Oracle and partner news, how-to articles for developers and DBAs, and more.
Dr. Dobb's Journal enables programmers to write the most efficient and sophisticated programs and help in daily programming quandaries.
InformationWeek is the only newsweekly you'll need to stay on top of the latest developments in information technology.
