EXTREME Overclocking
Home | Reviews | EOC Forums | File Downloads | RealTime Pricing Engine | Folding Stats Contact Us

7200RPM Ultra ATA/66 Hard Drive

Company: Western Digital
Product: 20.5 Hard Drive Retail Box Version
Street Price: ~ $185
Complete Spec's: http://www.westerndigital.com/products/drives/wd205bartl.html
Date Reviewed: March 18, 2000

 

First Impression:

Okay, like I said, I just got a new Western Digital hard drive today (even though I really don't need it) and I thought I would post some reviewage for everyone to ponder on. Given Western Digital's past history of recalls and not so hot quality I was pretty hesitant to make this purchase, but for $84 and a 3 year warranty, how could anyone pass up an offer like that?

Here's a quick comparison of the two HD's that I will be giving a benchmark of. Pretty similar spec's except the IBM has a couple more platters (cuz it's a bigger drive) so you think the performance would be the same, well read on to find out...

WD Expert 20.5GB Drive IBM 34GXP 34.2GB Drive
Size: 20.5GB
RPM:
7200
Transfer Mode:
Ultra ATA/66
Avg. Read Seek:
9.0ms
Avg. Full Stroke:
15.5ms
Avg. Latency:
4.17ms
Platters:
3
Heads:
6
Cache:
2 MB
Warranty: 3 Years
Size: 34.2GB
RPM:
7200
Transfer Mode:
Ultra ATA/66
Avg. Read Seek:
9.0ms
Avg. Full Stroke:
15.5ms
Avg. Latency:
4.17ms
Platters:
5
Heads:
10
Cache:
2 MB
Warranty: 3 Years

 

What's inside the box?

Well, to start out, it came in the typical generic Western Digital retail box. WD made sure to promote that the 7200 is 33% faster (spindle speed) than the 5400 with a nice graph on the back. The contents include:

1 - Box
1 - Western Digital 20.5GB hard drive
1 - 40-pin 80-conductor IDE Cable (A requirement if you are going to use it in ATA/66 Mode)
4 - Screws to mount the Hard Drive
1 - Extra Jumper (There even another extra in the back of the HD)
1 - Retail Installation Guide aka. User's Manual
1 - Quick Installation Guide aka. 8-step fold out roadmap
1 - Registration Card (U.S. Only)
1 - Data Lifeguard Tools Disk
1 - Extra jumper setting sheet (Sheesh, it's labeled on the HD & in the Manual how to set them!)

Click on each image for a close-up (about 800x600)

 

Installation & Benchmarks:

Installation is about as simple as installing any HD. Currently I only have 1 ATA/66 hard drive, and since I didn't want to chain them together, and WD gave me an extra ATA/66 cable, I just stuck it on my other ATA/66 channel. The test system is an Abit BP6 w/dual Celeron's (366 oc'ed to 550) with 256MB ECC PC133 IBM (Toshiba) SDRAM's running Windows NT 4.0 SP6a. It's actually my machine that I use daily. For comparison I benched my IBM Deskstar 34GXP 34.2GB 7200RPM ATA/66 hard drive.

Here are the results from Sisoft Sandra 99:

I took the UDMA scores that Sandra gives, and I benched my ZIP 250 (Internal IDE) just to give some comparison.

Drive Benchmark Score
WD 20.5 12,225
IBM 34.2 11,606
UDMA 8.4 7600
UDMA 6.4 6500
ZIP 250 1827

 

Conclusion:

Okay, so I am impressed! My IBM drive is pretty cluttered with files (about half full) so that could of affected the benchmark. But still, I am very pleased with the performance of the Western Digital drive. Judging from my past experience and from friends experiences, only time will tell if this is truly a good quality drive, or if it is going to die in 6 months! I would think after all this time they would finally work out the glitches in their production and all. One nice thing that WD does include is the Data Lifeguard disk which can run diagnostics and tell you if your drive is defective, even before you begin to notice something is seriously wrong with your drive. 

It's not the cheapest 20.5GB drive out there. Just checking out pricescan.com and you can see that Maxtor, IBM, and Seagate equivalent's are sold for $20-$25 cheaper. Still, that price difference could be retail box vs. bare drive. WD does have a $30 rebate still going on till May 27,2000 for the retail boxes only! Most people stick with brands that they are used to and don't go switching drives just to save a few bucks. Me personally, I like IBM, Quantum, and Seagate drives the most. I just haven't had too much luck with Western Digital, Maxtor, and Fujitsu drives in the past, but every now and then I try to give them a second chance.

Take Me To The Main Page

 

 

Most Downloaded Files
Recently Added Files
Compare Prices On Top Brands!
Search:
For:

Intel Processors
Core i7 - Haswell
i7-4770K  i7-4771  i7-4790  i7-4770  i7-4790S  i7-4770S

Core i5 - Haswell
i5-4670K  i5-4690  i5-4690S  i5-4590S  i5-4570  i5-4460  i5-4590  i5-4440S  i5-4430  i5-4440

Core i3 - Haswell
i3-4340  i3-4370  i3-4350  i3-4360  i3-4330  i3-4130T  i3-4160  i3-4130  i3-4150

AMD Processors
Vishera 8-Core AM3+
FX-9590  FX-9370  FX-8370  FX-8370E  FX-8350  FX-8320  FX-8320E

Vishera 6-Core AM3+
FX-6350  FX-6300

Kaveri 4-Core FM2+
A10-7850K  A10-7800  A10-7700K  A8-7600

Video Cards
nVidia GeForce GTX 900 Series
GTX 980  GTX 970  GTX 960

nVidia GeForce GTX 700 Series
GTX 780  GTX 760  GTX 750

AMD Radeon R9 Series
290X  290  285  280X  280  270X  270

AMD Radeon R7 Series
265  260X  250X  250  240

Search By Brand
ASUS  Diamond  eVGA  Gigabyte  MSI  PowerColor  PNY  Sapphire  Visiontek  XFX  Zotac

PC Memory
DDR3  DDR2  DDR

Motherboards
ASUS  ASRock  Biostar  ECS  eVGA  Foxconn  Gigabyte  Intel  MSI  Shuttle  Supermicro  Tyan 

Hard Drives & SSDs
Corsair  Crucial  Fujitsu  HGST  Intel  OCZ  Samsung  Sandisk  Seagate  Western Digital

Copyright ©2000-2016 EXTREME Overclocking. All rights reserved.
Disclaimer of Liability - Privacy Policy